How Do Bargain Sales Work? | Sharpe Group
Posted August 31st, 2017

How Do Bargain Sales Work?

A bargain sale is a sale to charity at a bargain price. The classic example is a sale of real estate to a charity at a price below fair market value (FMV).

Or supposedly below FMV. Charities need to be cautious when offered real estate at a supposed bargain price, unless the charity wants the real estate for its own purposes. Cautious because the “donor” may be inflating the property’s value or trying to offload a problem. These concerns usually vanish when the charity wants the property to further its mission.

In a true bargain sale (i.e., a sale truly at a bargain price), there are two tax consequences to the donor-seller: [1] the ability to claim a charitable deduction for the bargain element in the sale; and [2] the realization of gain if the asset in question has appreciated in value. Here’s an explanation of how the numbers work:

Concept: Assume we know:  FMV, the donor’s basis in the asset (B), and the selling price (SP).

The bargain element in the sale, for which the donor-seller may claim a charitable deduction, is FMV – SP.

The gain realized by the donor-seller is given by this formula:

Gain realized = (SP/FMV) x (FMV – B)

Example:  Assume FMV = $500,000; B = $300,000; and SP = $250,000. Donor-seller may claim a federal income tax charitable deduction (subject to all the usual limitations and valuation requirements) of $500,000 – $250,000, or $250,000.

Donor-seller realizes a gain equal to:

($250,000/$500,000) x ($500,000 – $300,000)

Which is equal to (1/2) x $200,000, or $100,000.

Bargain sales are relatively uncommon, except for gift annuities. A gift annuity funded with a noncash asset is a bargain sale of the asset and is treated as such, the only “twist” being that the realized gain is generally spread over the donor’s “life expectancy.”

by Jon Tidd, Esq

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sharpe Group Blog